News

Nature is changing, so legislation must be able to adapt as well

Maija Rantamäki
Forest

Over the past few decades, forest management has increasingly moved towards pursuing multiple benefits from the same forest at the same time. Forests provide habitats for species, sequester carbon, offer recreational benefits and supply renewable raw materials. 

At the same time, our knowledge of species and their habitats has increased, and structural features important for biodiversity have been strengthened. Finland has exceptionally comprehensive data on forest development, even by international standards. The Finnish National Forest Inventory, for example, provides a long-term time series on changes in forest structure and in structural features important for biodiversity. 

Meanwhile, the interpretation of EU nature legislation, more specifically the Birds and Habitats Directives, has evolved. In practical terms, the application of the species protection provisions of the two directives has been shaped in particular by the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. One example is the impact of the Voore Mets case in Estonia on the interpretation of the Birds Directive. This was reflected in updates to guidance on the Directive and also contributed to legislative changes in Finland. 

It is worth pausing here for a moment and look at the broader framework formed by legislation, case law and implementation guidance. Do they still enable Member States to target conservation measures in the most effective way? This question has been considered by the European Commission this year as part of the stress test of Birds and Habitats Directives, and the discussion will continue next year as the Commission assesses more closely whether legislative changes are needed. 

Climate change makes the question even more pressing 

Nature conservation must be capable of safeguarding biodiversity in a changing climate. The objective cannot simply be to preserve the current occurrence of species and habitat types unchanged, as species’ ranges are likely to shift and ecosystems will change with them. 

That is why assessing the nature legislations should not be considered taboo. Reopening the EU nature directives would be a major step, and any amendments should be based on a precise definition of the problems to be addressed and should be carefully targeted. At the same time, it is worth remembering that the Habitats Directive is already more than 30 years old and the Birds Directive 50 years old. 

It is reasonable to examine whether the directives, together with the case law that has developed around them, still provide the best framework for addressing today’s challenges: climate change, halting biodiversity loss, the need for legal certainty and Europe’s competitiveness. 

This is also a question of predictability. Nature legislation has significant implications for landowners, industries, investments and the availability of raw materials. If the practical meaning of key provisions continues to evolve through case law and guidance, the operating environment becomes difficult to anticipate. Fundamental questions cannot be addressed indefinitely simply by issuing new guidance. 

There is no question that Europe must halt biodiversity loss. At the same time, we need to safeguard our competitiveness, access to our own renewable raw materials and our capacity to adapt to a changing climate. 

Reviewing the directives is not about lowering conservation ambitions. Quite the opposite. It is about making nature conservation more effective while making legislation clearer, more predictable and more proportionate. For this reason, we should also be prepared to reopen the directives when necessary. 

News

You might also be interested in

Forest
Europe needs healthy and growing forests that sequester carbon, but it also needs renewable raw materials and wood-based products.
Forest

Wood-based products are rightly seen as an opportunity to move away from non-renewable raw materials and towards renewable alternatives. When

Climate and energy
In climate policy, nothing is ever normal: we’re either on the brink of disaster or facing opportunities so vast the