News

How many times does the sustainability of wood need to be proven?

Maija Rantamäki
Forest
Aerial view of a conifer forest in Finland

Wood-based products are rightly seen as an opportunity to move away from non-renewable raw materials and towards renewable alternatives. When promoting wood-based products, the general principle is that the wood used in them should be demonstrably sourced from sustainable sources. This principle is both understandable and important: consumers, businesses and policymakers need to be able to ensure that the raw materials used in products have been sourced in a demonstrably sustainable manner. However, less attention has been paid to the question of how extensively sustainability is already being verified today.

In Finland and elsewhere in Europe, the origin and sustainability of wood are monitored through several different systems. Forest use is governed by national forest legislation, EU legislation on nature, climate and energy, as well as regulations such as the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR). In addition, the sustainability of forest management is verified through widely used PEFC and FSC certification schemes and sustainable forest management guidelines.

At the same time, the EU is developing new product policy instruments aimed at improving the environmental sustainability of products. In this context, the idea has emerged that the sustainability of biomass used in products should also be demonstrated against separate criteria. This is being discussed, among other things, in connection with the implementation of the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR) and the development of the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF).

The forest industry considers that existing legislation governing wood procurement, together with current recommendations and certification schemes, should be sufficient to demonstrate the sustainability of biomass in wood sourcing. Common standards can be used at product level where they support the assessment of products’ environmental impacts without introducing new criteria for the sourcing of forest biomass. If separate product-specific criteria were introduced, they could create a vast and complex web of additional requirements at forest level, even though the same wood is used to manufacture a wide range of products. If the legality of the wood’s origin, the sustainability of forest management and traceability have already been demonstrated through legislation, regulatory oversight and certification, what added value would further product-level criteria provide?

The risk is regulatory duplication. From the perspective of businesses, additional criteria would make sourcing wood raw material more complex and increase the administrative burden.

An alternative approach is also being considered in the ongoing EU debate. Instead of creating new, separate systems, existing sustainability frameworks and recognised certification schemes could be used. This would allow both authorities and the market to rely on the same methods of demonstrating sustainability across different applications.

The competitiveness of the bioeconomy depends largely on its ability to replace non-renewable materials with renewable alternatives. The debate should therefore ask not only, “Is wood sustainable?”, but also, “How can sustainability be demonstrated as efficiently as possible?” If every new piece of legislation requires separate proof of the same thing, there is a risk that the focus will shift from improving sustainability to increasing paperwork.

Ultimately, the question is very simple. If the sustainability of wood has already been reliably demonstrated when the wood is sourced, how many times does the same thing need to be proven?

News

You might also be interested in

Forest
We must halt biodiversity loss while safeguarding competitiveness, renewable raw materials and climate resilience.
Forest
Europe needs healthy and growing forests that sequester carbon, but it also needs renewable raw materials and wood-based products.
Climate and energy
In climate policy, nothing is ever normal: we’re either on the brink of disaster or facing opportunities so vast the