China is playing an increasingly significant role in shaping the competitive conditions of industrial sectors. Alongside the automotive and chemical industries, this is also evident in the forest industry: over the past 20 years, China’s share of global chemical forest industry production has surpassed those of both Europe and the United States. The quality and competitiveness of Chinese production have improved, but the key question is whether competition is taking place on a level playing field.
China’s industrial growth is not a problem in itself, provided that competition is fair. The focus, however, is increasingly on the rules of the game. In many sectors, China is systematically expanding industrial production with the support of massive state subsidies. This puts downward pressure on global market prices and displaces competitors operating on market terms. This is not normal competition, but state-funded expansion into markets that China considers economically or strategically important.
The result can be state-supported overcapacity that is channelled into export markets and pushes down prices. This changes the terms of competition. European companies are competing not only against the efficiency and products of Chinese companies, but also against the financial resources of the Chinese state. At the same time, Chinese products are increasingly being redirected towards the European market as a result of the escalation of tariffs driven by the United States.
The scale of the problem is illustrated by the anti-dumping duties and countervailing measures already imposed on Chinese products. A recent study prepared for the European Parliament also offers little prospect of the situation easing. It identifies overcapacity across several Chinese industrial sectors and expects competitive pressure to continue or intensify. It recommends the full and sector-specific use of the EU’s trade defence instruments.
According to the OECD, state support has played a significant role in the growing market shares of Chinese companies. If sustained over a prolonged period, price competition supported by state subsidies erodes the profitability, investment capacity and production capacity of European plants. Trade defence measures should therefore not be regarded as unjustified protectionism. Rather, they are a means of countering distortions of competition and preserving strategically important production, expertise and value chains in Europe.
China takes advantage of market cycles
China’s competitive advantage is based not only on production, but also on its ability to take advantage of economic and market cycles. While European companies are forced to adjust their production when demand is weak, China can often build up inventories, maintain production levels and prepare for the next upturn.
This has been evident, for example, during the Strait of Hormuz crisis. China has drawn on strategic oil reserves accumulated earlier and purchased oil from the market when prices have been relatively low. Time series for the forest industry’s pulp market point to a similar pattern: China has increased its purchases during periods of falling pulp prices.
China Shock 2.0
The first China shock of the 2000s affected labour-intensive industries. The phenomenon is now different, also from the perspective of the forest industry. China is challenging Europe in sectors on which Europe is relying to deliver the green transition, greater self-sufficiency, the bioeconomy and competitiveness. The focus of the debate is no longer solely on trade with China. Increasingly, it is about competing with China in both existing and emerging industrial products.
Brussels and Beijing are currently negotiating ways to address the EU’s significant trade deficit with China. The rapid growth of Chinese exports has increased pressure on European manufacturers and heightened concerns about the erosion of Europe’s industrial base. High-profile factory closures, including in the automotive and chemical industries, have reinforced these concerns.
Trade Commissioner Maroš Šefčovič is due to visit Beijing in October as part of the negotiations. He has stated that the EU is prepared to take action if sufficient progress has not been achieved by then.
For the export-driven forest industry, open and rules-based international trade remains a fundamental principle. In the changed operating environment, however, this must be complemented, where necessary, by stronger measures such as strategic partnerships and EU trade policy instruments. If carefully targeted, these measures can help ensure a level playing field and strengthen the conditions for manufacturing industry in Europe.